If you’ve been injured in Crawfordsville, Indiana, due to someone else’s negligence, having an experienced personal injury attorney is key to protecting your rights and securing the compensation you deserve.

If you’re looking for a personal injury attorney in Crawfordsville, Indianapolis or the surrounding areas, our practice brings years of experience and a proven track record of success.
No matter the claim, we’re here to guide you every step of the way. Keep reading to explore our practice areas, find answers to common questions and learn how we can help you get the justice you’re entitled to.
Types of Personal Injury Cases We Litigate
At Poynter & Bucheri, we fight for injury victims in a wide range of areas, including:
Car Accidents

A car accident occurs when a vehicle collides with another vehicle, object or person, often resulting in injuries and financial losses.
Most crashes aren’t just “accidents”—they happen because drivers act negligently, recklessly or carelessly, and investigators often find someone at fault.
Insurers prioritize profits over recovery, making it crucial to fight for fair compensation. Taking your case to jury trial may be necessary to secure what you are owed.
Truck Accidents
A truck accident involves a collision with a commercial vehicle like a semi-truck or big rig, leading to devastating injuries and extensive property damage.
These cases are more involved than regular car accidents, as multiple parties are potentially liable—drivers, trucking companies and insurers.
You need an experienced practice that knows federal regulations and how to enforce accountability. Opposing lawyers and insurers will exploit any error to deny your settlement.
Dog Bite Accidents

A dog bite accident occurs when a dog attacks a human, leading to physical injuries and emotional distress that can disrupt daily life and work. In some cases, victims may require medical treatment, surgery or therapy to recover fully.
Indiana follows a strict liability law for dog bites, meaning owners are responsible for injuries if their dog attacks someone lawfully on their property, regardless of prior aggression. This law states that victims can seek compensation without needing to prove the owner knew their dog was dangerous.
Wrongful Death
Wrongful death claims arise when negligence or intent causes the loss of human life, leaving families with emotional and financial burdens. Since victims can’t seek justice, loved ones can file for medical bills, funeral costs, lost income and punitive damages.
These civil claims, separate from criminal cases, hold individuals, businesses or entities accountable. If negotiations fail, our firm is ready to fight for our client’s justice in a jury trial.
Slip-and-Fall Injuries

A slip-and-fall claim arises when dangerous conditions like wet floors, uneven sidewalks or poor lighting cause injury on someone’s property. These accidents can result in severe injuries and costly medical bills.
Proving liability in slip-and-fall cases is challenging, as property owners frequently attempt to shift blame or argue they weren’t aware of the hazard. Our practice pushes back against these tactics, demonstrating that the owner failed to take proper precautions to keep the area safe.
Elements That Might Affect Your Personal Injury Case Success
Here are some of the most important factors we have found that impact cases:
Strong Evidence & Documentation
Strong evidence—like medical records, accident reports, witness statements and photos—makes your claim harder to dispute. It proves the defendant had a duty of care, violated it through negligence, and caused your injuries. If gaps in evidence exist, they can be used against you.
Severity of Injuries & Medical Treatment
One common error we find is clients failing to document every part of their injury from the date of the incident. Seeking immediate treatment, tracking medications, bills and appointments, and documenting recovery all help prove the true extent of the injuries. Never skip doctor follow-ups.
Legal Representation & Strategy
Contacting a personal injury attorney familiar with the Indianapolis area and its laws can make or break your case. A skilled lawyer negotiates, gathers evidence and fights insurers to protect the client. Our Indianapolis area lawyers are known for aggressive advocacy in personal injury practice.
Insurance & Settlement Negotiations
Never speak with the other party’s insurance company without your attorney—insurers twist words to minimize liability. From the date we take your case, our firm handles all communication to protect your rights. A strong case and skilled negotiation ensure you receive the justice and compensation you are entitled to.
Emergency Services in Crawfordsville, Indiana
- Fire Department: 100 S Water Street Crawfordsville, IN 47933, Phone: 765-362-1277
- Police Department: 311 N Green Street Crawfordsville, IN 47933, Phone: 765-362-3762
- Franciscan Health:1710 Lafayette Rd. Crawfordsville, IN 47933, 765-362-2800
- Montgomery County Superior Court: 100 E Main St Crawfordsville, IN 47933, (765) 364-6447
Living in Crawfordsville, Indiana

Crawfordsville, Indiana, is the perfect blend of history and nature. While home to the most museums in the state, it also offers endless outdoor adventures, from canoeing on Sugar Creek to camping at Shades State Park. This small-town gem finds the perfect balance of charm while staying close to Indianapolis.
With an active community, personal injury risks exist, making legal support necessary. Poynter & Bucheri has served Crawfordsville for years, bringing a deep knowledge of the local court system and personal injury cases for each client in the region.
Crawfordsville, Indiana Personal Injury FAQs
What Should I Say if the At-Fault Driver’s Insurance Company Contacts Me?
If the at-fault driver’s insurance company contacts you, avoid giving detailed statements or admitting fault. In Indiana, you’re not required to speak with them, and anything you say can be used to reduce or deny your claim. Instead, refer them to your attorney.
Who Pays for My Personal Injury Medical Bills?

In Indiana, the at-fault party is responsible for covering medical bills, but their insurance won’t pay until a settlement is found.
In the meantime, you may need to use health insurance, MedPay or work with doctors who agree to be paid from your future settlement.
A skilled personal injury lawyer can help you recover the full cost of your medical expenses and protect your rights throughout this process.
How Much Compensation Can I Expect From My Wrongful Death Case?
Compensation for a wrongful death claim in Indiana depends on the circumstances. State law limits damages in certain cases, such as medical malpractice and adult wrongful death without dependents. Our firm guarantees every client gets expert guidance to maximize their claim and seek justice for their loved one.
Let Us Get Started on Your Case Today!
If you’ve been in an accident, you deserve the best legal practice on your side. At Poynter & Bucheri, we’ve successfully found winning solutions for clients in Crawfordsville and the Indianapolis area.
Don’t settle for less. Visit our contact page or call us at 1-800-265-9881 to discuss your case and take the first step toward the maximum compensation and recovery you are entitled to.